For general questions, please fill out our form and we'll be in touch!

Name *
Name

22-42 McWilliams Pl
Jersey City, NJ, 07302
United States

201-984-0530

Churning adventurous ice cream made organic, grass-fed dairy and all the best New Jersey produce.

FAQ's

Ice Cream Speak

Organic - Our ice cream is made from organic milk and cream. Organic means that there are no GMO's, no antibiotics, no steroids, no pesticides in the milk and that the cows are grass-fed. Cows that eat grass produce more-flavorful milk that is higher in vitamins and essential fatty-acids than conventional milk.

Sustainable - We go through a lot of bowls, cups and spoons at our shop. So we make sure that our disposables are made of fully compostable, recyclable or biodegradable substances
such as sugar cane, birch
wood or PLA. 

Creamery - Technically a place on a dairy farm where the cream is separated from the whole milk. The word is often used for stores that sell dairy products like cheese, yogurt or our favorite, ice cream.

Chip - We use this term all the time in place of the full term "Chocolate Chip." Our chips our found in popular flavors like Lavender Chip and Malt Chip. They are thin, very delicate and made from Mast Brothers 73% dark chocolate. 

Cold Brew - Cold brew is a method for brewing iced coffee. We keep our Stumptown Cold Brew on tap at the shop from April through October.

Puppy Froyo - Puppy Froyo is frozen yogurt for your pup! Our Froyo contains non-fat yogurt, peanut butter and banana. We top it all off with a tiny dog treat. Yes, humans can eat the Puppy Froyo, but without any added sugar or salt, it just won't be as appealing as it is to your pup. Plus, $1 from every sale goes directly to See Spot Rescued, our partner charity, to help save all the puppies.

About Our Shop

Seating - We have benches inside the store and outside the store for seating. The benches inside seat 8 altogether. The benches outside seat 12 altogether. We have awnings over the benches outside to provide shade. We are also directly across from beautiful Hamilton Park where there is abundant outdoor seating. Unfortunately, our store is too small to rent out for private parties. However, we do have  an ice cream cart and an ice cream truck available to rent. Click here to see our catering options!

Flavors - We are a small batch ice cream maker, which means our flavors rotate frequently. Because of this fast-paced rotation, we do not post our current flavors on the website, though we do highlight new or returning favorite flavors on social media. 

Restrooms - We do not have a public restroom in our shop.

Water - Bottled water is available for purchase at the shop or if you bring a reusable bottle, we will gladly fill it up for you.

Payments - We have a $10 credit card minimum. We do not accept $100 bills. We do not accept mutilated bills. We cannot hold product without payment. All sales are final. 

Sales Tax - All of our prices already include sales tax.

Ordering - All orders for ice cream cakes and baked goods must be placed through our online store here.

Pets - We only allow service animals in our shop. This policy is strictly enforced by the Jersey City Department of Health and Human Services.

And lastly - It's ice cream. So be nice.


We no longer offer baked cakes at the shop. We do, however, always have cupcakes ready to pick up. You can also order cupcakes, other baked goods and our ice cream cakes through our online store


A Note About Serving Size

Our small size is 4 ounces of ice cream. You can choose up to 2 flavors in our small size because we portion our ice cream in half size (2 ounce) scoops in order to allow you to sample multiple flavors in one serving. Our ice cream has very low overrun, which means there is very little air in it. When we serve you 4 ounces of ice cream, you are getting 4 ounces of dense, creamy flavor, not 4 ounces of air. We believe in handmade, small-batch quality over mass-produced, air-filled quantity and we hope that once you taste our ice cream, you'll believe in it too.

Questions and Concerns

Please send an e-mail to sweets@milksugarlove.com or call the store directly at 201.984.0530.