Order Now | Milk Sugar Love

Email Signup

First Name* Last Name* Email*

Please check errors in the form above

Thank you for signing up for email updates!

Red Velvet Ice Cream Cake

0.00

Cream Cheese ice cream, Red Velvet cake, White Chocolate Ganache, Festive Sprinkles

Allergens: Wheat, Milk, Soy, Eggs

6” serves up to 10. 8” serves up to 16.

Quantity

Size Size

Please check errors in the form above

The Classic

0.00

Vanilla Bean ice cream, Chocolate Cookie Crunch, Classic Chocolate ice cream, Rainbow Sprinkles

Allergens: Wheat, Milk, Soy

6” serves up to 10. 8” serves up to 16. Quarter Sheet serves up to 30.

Quantity

Size Size

Leave a special message on the cake

Please check errors in the form above

The Chilltown

0.00

Two giant chocolate chip cookies filled with Vanilla Bean ice cream and rolled in Rainbow Sprinkles

Allergens: Wheat, Milk, Soy, Eggs

6” serves up to 10. 8” serves up to 16.

Quantity

Size Size

Leave a special message on the cake

Please check errors in the form above

The Fruity Pebble Mac Daddy

0.00

Two giant French macarons filled with Fruity Pebbles ice cream and rolled in Fruity Pebbles. Because of the nature of the macarons, we cannot inscribe messages on this cake.

Allergens: Tree Nuts, Milk, Soy

6” serves up to 10. 8” serves up to 16.

Quantity

Size Size

Please check errors in the form above

Ice Cream Sandwich Party
serves up to 20

149.00

Your choice of 1 gallon of ice cream and 40 fresh-baked chocolate chip cookies per party, plus rainbow sprinkles and Chocolate Cookie Crumble for rolling. Includes cups and spoons.

Catering packages do not include staffing or cart or truck rental.

Quantity

Ice Cream Flavor Options Ice Cream Flavor Options

Please check errors in the form above

Ice Cream Sundae Party
serves up to 20

149.00

Your choice of 1 gallon of ice cream per party, plus waffle cone crumble, brownie bites, rainbow sprinkles and chocolate sauce for all. Includes cups and spoons.

Catering packages do not include staffing or cart or truck rental.

Quantity

Ice Cream Flavor Options Ice Cream Flavor Options

Please check errors in the form above

6 Mini Macaron Ice Cream Sandwiches

18.00

Flavor Assortment:
Chocolate Sprinkle
Mint Chip
Strawberry
Cookies 'n' Cream
Fruity Pebbles
Stumptown Coffee

These flavors are a set. No substitutions.

Regular Ice Cream Sandwiches

6.00

Sandwiches come prepackaged with ingredient labels and allergen information.

Flavor Choices:

The American
Fudge Brownies filled with Peanut Butter ice cream, candied peanuts, dipped in chocolate and sprinkled with Sea Salt

The Doughboy
Layers of Cookie Dough filled with Classic Chocolate ice cream, dipped in chocolate and confetti sprinkles

The Coffee Chip
Chocolate Chip cookies filled with Stumptown Coffee ice cream

The Fruity Pebble Mac Daddy
Fruity Pebble French Macarons filled with Fruity Pebble ice cream and rolled in Fruity Pebbles

Quantity

Flavor Options

For orders of 6 dozen or more, please call the store at 201-984-0530.

The American

The Doughboy

The Coffee Chip

The Fruity Pebble Mac Daddy

Please check errors in the form above

Bulk Ice Cream

50.00

Your choice of any of our classic flavors of ice cream in a gallon container. Serves 20 people.

Quantity

Ice Cream Flavor Options Ice Cream Flavor Options

Please check errors in the form above

One Dozen Macarons

29.00

12 French Macarons packaged in a brown slider box.

Quantity

Flavor Choices

Chocolate

Pistachio

Dulce de Leche

Raspberry

Passion Fruit

Birthday

Please check errors in the form above

One Dozen Assorted Cookies

16.50

1 dozen cookies in a bakery box.
Assortment varies according to the day. Please call the store for flavors, 201-984-0530.

One Dozen Assorted Bars

48.00

1 dozen assorted bars in a bakery box.

Quantity

Flavors

Raspberry Crumb

Sea Salt Brownie

Toffee Walnut Blondie

Magic Bar

Matcha Brownie

PB&J

Walnut Brownie

Please check errors in the form above